Is
the use of social media and social networking sites helpful for student
learning in the classroom? In some schools, students and teachers use social media
and social networking sites in classes for educational purposes. But is the use
of these sites effective in learning?
Some
teachers use social networking websites, such as Facebook and Twitter, as a
form of communication between the students and themselves. “Many educators,
including ourselves, believe that these tools offer new educational affordances
and avenues for students to interact with each other and with their teachers or
tutors” (Poellhuber). They create a group or a page and post assignments,
references, lectures, and questions on it. This creates a way for the students
to interact with each other, ask questions, and see upcoming assignments. There
have been some studies observing students who use Twitter in class. Some of the
students agreed that the use of Twitter in classes demonstrated its usefulness.
Thus to enhance student learning, they advised its use permanently in all
classrooms (Lin, Hoffman and Borengasser) .
These
teachers, along with others, also use social media websites such as YouTube in
their lessons to teach students. YouTube happens to possess videos on nearly
anything; so to assume that educational videos also exist on this website seems
reasonable. Mr. Polk, a history teacher at Arlee High School, uses YouTube
videos in his classes daily. He shows students in his Government class videos
about the news and recent events that appear important. In other classes, he
requires that all students watch videos on historical events to gain more
knowledge of the past.
On
the other hand, some teachers continue to argue that educational videos do
exist on social media and social networking websites; but they question whether
or not the use of these websites truly have a positive effect on students’
learning. “Incorporating Twitter in courses will require careful consideration
of scaffolding, modeling, privacy and course design. Questions remain as to
whether the informal social focus of Twitter may overwhelm attempts to use it
in more structured educational settings” (Lin, Hoffman and Borengasser) . Some teachers still
remain concerned that these social networking sites will cause more of a
distraction than they will an affective form of education and learning. They
believe that students will not use the websites for their intended purposes in
class; they will simply use them as they do outside of school (Lin, Hoffman and Borengasser) . This may occur,
however, students should also distinguish between whether the time and location
calls for using these social websites in a social manner, and it does not.
Students show responsibility as well as trustworthiness when they use these
websites correctly. Teachers will know when students do not use the sites
correctly through their performance, interaction in discussions in class, and
the students’ response to questions directed towards them in class. If students
become more involved in class activities the minimal confrontations due to the
website’s misuse could potentially be worth the fight, corresponding to Page
Abe and Nickolas A. Jordan’s findings.
I
took a poll on Facebook asking my Facebook “friends” if they thought the use of
social media and social networking sites used in education prove helpful in
learning or not. Fifty percent of the people who answered believed these social
sites proved helpful for them. Yet, the other fifty percent expressed that
these websites could not be helpful. “…Alternatives to face-to-face teaching
need to be explored. These alternatives will only work if they prove useful to
students” (VanDoorn, George, Antoinette A. Eklund).
I
personally feel as though social media and social networking websites have the
capability to help both students and teachers in education. However, I also
believe the effectiveness of these sites in student learning will vary between students.
As stated by Liang, Commins, and Duffy: “The tools of social
media must be tailored to foster engagement, authenticity, empowerment, and
conflict tolerance even while the involved parties are connecting virtually and
often asynchronously.” Thus if students use these social websites correctly, I see
these social sites as becoming highly effective in learning. In the present
day, young adults find more interest in technology and social connectivity websites,
resulting in a necessity for change. There have been recent studies done in which
a social connectivity website is created for school purposes and concluded the
end result as a positive reaction from today’s youth (Liang,
Commins and Duffy) .
This social connectivity web site created a constructive, dynamic, energetic,
and secure place where teens could express their individual opinions and
beliefs. Therefore, it may seem more suitable for all schools to consider using
a technological approach that will appeal to students in this generation (Liang, Commins
and Duffy) .
Acknowledging
both sides of the debate, social networking and social media websites could
either result in revolutionizing education and teaching or it could end in
students abusing them. Either way, we will never know if we don’t try using
them for educational purposes. If students begin abusing this privilege, the
school can easily take it away. If the use of these social sites has a positive
result, the schools can continue their use. Regardless of the outcome, I have
yet to find a reason why schools should not at least try using these social websites
for educational uses.
Works Cited
Abe,
Paige, and Nickolas A. Jordan. "Integrating Social Media into the
Classroom Curriculum." About Campus
18.1 (2013): 16-20. ERIC. Web. 16
Oct. 2013.
Liang, Belle, Meghan Commins and Nicole Duffy. "Using Social Media to
Engage Youth: Education, Social Justice, & Humanitarianism." (2010):
ERIC. Web. 15 Oct. 2013
Lin,
Meng-Fen Grace, Ellen S. Hoffman, and Claire Borengasser. "Is Social
Media too Social for Class? A Case Study of Twitter Use." Techtrends: Linking Research and Practice
to Improve Learning 57.2 (2013): 39-45. ERIC. Web. 16 Oct. 2013.
Poellhuber,
Bruno, and Terry Anderson. "Distance Students' Readiness for Social Media
and Collaboration." International
Review Of Research in Open and Distance Learning 12.6 (2011): 102-125. ERIC. Web. 16 Oct. 2013.
VanDoorn,
George, and Antoinette A. Eklund. "Face to Facebook: Social Media and the
Learning and Teaching Potential of Symmetrical, Synchronous
Communication." Journal of
University Teaching and Learning Practice 10.1 (2013): ERIC. Web. 16 Oct. 2013.
Hi, Khristina:
ReplyDeleteI appreciated how you thoughtfully considered both sides of the debate on whether or not social networking and social media Websites should be used in the classroom.
In my opinion, many types of technology, including social networking and social media Websites, can be used to enhance learning and the creative "sharing" of what is being learned. However, the emphasis should be on "enhancing" rather than "replacing" traditional reading, critical thinking, and writing skills. Technology should be used when it seems appropriate for a particular lesson plan and fits in well with the learning goals of that lesson plan; technology should not be used just for the sake of "being high-tech." I think that your teacher, Ms. Baldwin, does an excellent job of incorporating technology to enhance learning and the sharing of ideas. The blogs that you and your fellow students are creating are a good example of that.
Finally, I agree with your concluding point, which is that we can't really know if using social networking and social media Websites in the classroom is or is not effective until we try it.
Hi Khristina,
ReplyDeleteI also wanted to say that I liked the fact that you considered both sides of the argument. What I liked even more, however, was your decision to take it one step further and do some research and come up with conclusions of your own.
I believe that technology in all of its numerous and wonderful forms, from the most academic web tool imaginable to good old twitter or Facebook can enhance learning and the way that we communicate. I agree with Kari who said that technology shouldn't be used just to use it; there should be a purpose. I also don't think that technology should replace traditional classroom approaches to learning, but when used correctly they should allow learning to expand.
Your final point of taking the time to try using the technology in a meaningful way in a classroom before banning or saying that it hinders learning is a valid point. We won't know if learning is hindered or advanced due to twitter or Facebook if we don't try. Because teachers are the ones who would have to initiate the use of such mediums, if they are abused they could very easily be taken away from the classroom use.
Overall great essay and engagement with the topic. If I was unsure if I thought technology could be helpful before your last paragraph would have helped me make a decision.